LooseSuits Thread: Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Scrivs — Fri, 27 Apr 2007 01:26:21

See I don't think they will lose traffic until people get tired of the stories they are seeing on the homepage. People still hit up Digg, but with less submissions it means a tighter group of sites can dominate.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Fri, 27 Apr 2007 01:25:07

I'm just not sure there's enough long term data available (to the public) to prove or disprove that.

I think it's a seasonal dip but I'll be the first to admin that I'm not a technology "expert". I don't track all the PR wind coming out the back of all the tech companies... There could be tons of stuff going on.

I would, however, wait for an entire year's worth of news before saying they're losing traffic. We could also do with knowing the numbers of submissions for each month.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Tyme — Thu, 26 Apr 2007 19:52:18

That's the thing, they should be more because they have more sections now but they remained the same meaning they've lost submissions. Maybe they've reached a plateau. Don't get me wrong they get a lot of submissions but from a business standpoint it should be more.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Thu, 26 Apr 2007 19:24:32

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

I've just noticed what you're asking... No I think the submissions are about the same size on average.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Thu, 26 Apr 2007 18:07:25

But then again the traffic has nothing to do with whether or not they are getting less submissions. I wonder if people got so frustrated of never reaching the homepage.

True enough, but submissions do have a lot to do with seasonal technology trends and also improvements (very gradual) in the duplicate detection system.

I thought there was a stat showing how many submissions digg gets but after 30 minutes of looking, I can't find the bugger.

Both WoW and Digg are full of asshats.

That's the internet for you...

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Bartoneus — Thu, 26 Apr 2007 17:40:57

Oli: Both WoW and Digg are full of asshats. That is the basis for comparing them.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Scrivs — Wed, 25 Apr 2007 00:07:58

But then again the traffic has nothing to do with whether or not they are getting less submissions. I wonder if people got so frustrated of never reaching the homepage.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 23:40:29

I meant to say it had a massive impact on the reach.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 22:54:55

How can you compare a game to a news/social-content site? One has a fairly fixed lifespan (get to level 60... and...? that's about it) while the news keeps coming on Digg.

People visit digg for the links, not the digg site itself. There's very little in the way of meaningful social interaction there other than burying twats in the comments and slandering microsoft... All fun.

The tech section isn't just a section. It's a section with the most subsections. It's the default section. You don't get stories about cats up trees etc if you go to digg.com unless they're armed with a frickin laser or they're using their macbook to hack their neighbours wifi.

Introducing all the new sections had a MASSIVE impact on the traffic throughput! Look at April 2006. Look how their reach doubled. Sure they've got a long way to go before they're completely mainstream but for the love of god, do they need more traffic?

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Bartoneus — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 22:45:37

It is bound to happen with any large congregation of asshats, WoW is seeing a bit of plateauing also so I imagine the same thing is happening to Digg.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

peroty — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 22:42:50

I know the tech section is still there, but it's just that, a section.
I used to hit Digg to find interesting things, and now I read the entire first page, and just go, meh.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Scrivs — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 22:33:43

That's true, but the point still remains that the other categories are starting to dominate the site now and given the demographic of Digg I don't know how well that will work. I think when they added the new sections they meant for them to bring in new audiences, but that doesn't seem to have occurred.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 20:17:43

In fairness to it, the tech-only side still exists. You can screw down on the technology sections through both preferences and RSS.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

peroty — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 19:32:52

I stopped visiting Digg when they branched out from being a tech only site. Digg used to be like a huge list of cool links and interesting stories. Now it's a teeming mess of pop culture. Not that there's anything wrong with it. I just preferred the tech-only Digg.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

joeylomanto — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 18:18:09

I hate to admit it.. but I find digg extremely entertaining.. I read it everymorning :( boo me... i suck...

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 17:46:14

Haha I can share that sentiment...

Too many content aggregating sites like the Gawker network's sites that keep reposting other people's stuff, getting it all over digg and taking all the advertising revenue...

I've got no problem with sites like that posting entries like that, but Digg shouldn't be taking submissions from them if that's what 90% of their content is.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Tyme — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 17:45:30

I zoomed in more - the six month graph.

One rule I would love for them to implement: the story submitted must be the link of the originating author. I'm not talking about You Tube - I'm talking about the writer who took the time to write an article for a bigger site to mash it up and link to it, resulting for the bigger site to get on Digg.

edit: so much for Alexa's widget working haha

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

seopher — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 17:32:02

Oli that didn't make sense... Or I've lost my marbles.

Digg isn't the site it once was, it seems to bring the same few sites to the top of the pile time and time again. I wouldn't mind so much if mine was one of them...

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Oli — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 17:26:05

No it's just seasonal like all technology news.

You can't really tell the seasons from that graph because Digg is so new, but that's just how tech news works. you have busy seasons where people are just going completely schitz over a few products (ala iphone) and then you get the dry season (summer) where nothing very much happens at all...

Digg won't go anywhere until there's something taking the traffic away from it. At the moment, I don't think there's anything that is as wide and powerful.

If you look at the traffic graph, you'll see that everything is pretty stable.

Why? I thought I just said it should be peaking and dropping off seasonally... Well yes... But when there's less news, fewer people look at more pages, actually looking for stories... At least that makes sense in my head.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

jackosh — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 16:28:37

my opinion:

digg was a fad. just like anything that becomes extremely popular really quickly, the popularity is bound to die off!

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Tyme — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 16:16:56

I just looked at an Alexa graph (I know it's not accurate but it does show trends) and it is showing an overall decrease in in traffic. Ironically this is after their improved site design, adding more content (podcasts).

Don't get me wrong, they are still getting a lot of traffic (enough to bring a server down) but from more than one source, there is a decline. Perhaps they have finally matured and are plateauing.

I've never been a real Digg fan but the truth is the stuff being submitted (making it to the front page) is mostly from the top sites in the industry - ones most people are subscribed to or I ended up hearing about anyway. Right now on the front page:

Yahoo
NYT
Gizmodo
Lifehacker

Digg lost it's usefulness.

Is Digg getting less and less submissions?

Scrivs — Tue, 24 Apr 2007 14:16:52

Tyme pointed this out to me yesterday, but she has noticed that Digg seems to be getting less submissions and I noticed that more often the top stories are getting a lesser amount of diggs. Does this mean less is happening on the site or is stuff just flying by so fast nobody can keep up? If you have observed a rise or fall I would like to hear your observations.